Bullion dealer reviews

Independent, methodology-driven reviews of the major US bullion dealers we track. We weight live premium consistency (25%), BBB grade (20%), shipping speed (15%), return policy (15%), payment methods (15%), and customer service (10%) into a 1.0–4.7 star rating, calibrated to our curated review set.

Read our full methodology. Reviews refresh as dealer policies change; live premium data refreshes nightly.

DealerOur ratingFoundedBBBShippingReturns
APMEX★★★★4.01999A+3 days7 daysReview →
BGASC★★★3.92012A+7 days5 daysReview →
Hero Bullion★★★3.520202 days5 daysReview →
JM Bullion★★★★4.02011A+1 days5 daysReview →
Money Metals★★★3.82010A+3 daysReview →
SD Bullion★★★★4.02012A+2 days3 daysReview →